The Toronto Arenas couldn't pull it off against the Ottawa Senators, 2 to 1, in overtime on January 28, 1919.
Senators
7-5-0
Arenas
3-8-0
Team
SEN
TAN
1
0
2
3
OT
Total
1st period
Harry Cameron assisted by Eddie Gerard
2nd period
Harry Mummery assisted by Alf Skinner
Harry Cameron unassisted