The New York Americans couldn't pull it off against the Montreal Maroons, 5 to 4, in overtime on January 4, 1934.
2nd period
MMR
NYA
Jimmy Ward (EV) assisted by Hooley Smith and Baldy Northcott
1
0
Ron Martin (EV) assisted by Normie Himes and Bill Brydge
1
1
3rd period
MMR
NYA
Baldy Northcott (EV) assisted by Jimmy Ward
2
1
Baldy Northcott (EV) unassisted
3
1
Lloyd Gross (EV) assisted by Hal Picketts
3
2
Ron Martin (EV) assisted by Lloyd Gross and Walter Jackson
3
3
OT
MMR
NYA
Earl Robinson (EV) unassisted
4
3
Eddie Burke (EV) assisted by Lloyd Klein and Red Conn
4
4
Hooley Smith (EV) unassisted
5
4