The Montreal Canadiens couldn't pull it off against the New York Americans, 2 to 1, in overtime on January 5, 1932.
Americans
6-9-6
Canadiens
8-9-3
Team
NYA
MTL
1
0
2
3
OT
Total
2nd period
Wildor Larochelle assisted by Howie Morenz
3rd period
Charley McVeigh assisted by Vern Ayres and Normie Himes
Charley McVeigh unassisted