The Toronto Maple Leafs couldn't pull it off against the Colorado Avalanche, 3 to 2, in overtime on October 17, 2011.
2nd period
COL
TOR
Phil Kessel (EV) assisted by Dion Phaneuf
0
1
Daniel Winnik (EV) assisted by Ryan O'Reilly and Jan Hejda
1
1
Milan Hejduk (PP) assisted by Erik Johnson and Paul Stastny
2
1
3rd period
COL
TOR
Nikolay Kulemin (EV) assisted by Dion Phaneuf and Clarke MacArthur
2
2
OT
COL
TOR
David Jones (EV) assisted by Kyle Quincey
3
2