The Detroit Red Wings couldn't pull it off against the Toronto Maple Leafs, 5 to 4, on November 1, 1970.
1st period
TOR
DET
Frank Mahovlich (PP) assisted by Alex Delvecchio and Gary Bergman
0
1
2nd period
TOR
DET
Nick Libett (EV) assisted by Alex Delvecchio
0
2
Mike Pelyk (EV) assisted by Dave Keon and Garry Monahan
1
2
Norm Ullman (PP) assisted by Paul Henderson and Ron Ellis
2
2
Frank Mahovlich (PP) assisted by Alex Delvecchio and Wayne Connelly
2
3
Dave Keon (EV) assisted by Brad Selwood
3
3
Bruce MacGregor (EV) assisted by Tom Webster
3
4
Dave Keon (EV) unassisted
4
4
3rd period
TOR
DET
Guy Trottier (EV) assisted by Mike Walton and Jim Dorey
5
4