The Washington Capitals couldn't pull it off against the Tampa Bay Lightning, 4 to 3, in a shootout on November 23, 2005.
1st period
TBL
WSH
Andrew Cassels (PP) assisted by Alex Ovechkin and Jeff Halpern
0
1
2nd period
TBL
WSH
Matt Pettinger (EV-PS) unassisted
0
2
Brian Sutherby (EV) assisted by Matt Bradley
0
3
Dan Boyle (EV) assisted by Fredrik Modin and Brad Richards
1
3
Rob DiMaio (EV) assisted by Dave Andreychuk and Nolan Pratt
2
3
3rd period
TBL
WSH
Dan Boyle (EV) assisted by Dave Andreychuk and Martin Cibak
3
3