The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the Pittsburgh Penguins, 3 to 2, on November 7, 2005.
1st period
PIT
NYR
Mario Lemieux (EV) assisted by Sergei Gonchar and Josef Melichar
1
0
2nd period
PIT
NYR
Sidney Crosby (EV) assisted by Ric Jackman and Steve Poapst
2
0
3rd period
PIT
NYR
Ziggy Palffy (EV) assisted by Ryan Whitney
3
0
Ryan Hollweg (EV) assisted by Jason Ward and Darius Kasparaitis
3
1
Marcel Hossa (EV) assisted by Steve Rucchin and Ryan Hollweg
3
2