The Ottawa Senators couldn't pull it off against the New York Rangers, 4 to 3, on December 14, 1933.
1st period
NYR
SEN
Murray Murdoch (PP) assisted by Cecil Dillon and Frank Boucher
1
0
Butch Keeling (EV) unassisted
2
0
2nd period
NYR
SEN
Des Roche (EV) assisted by Earl Roche and Carl Voss
2
1
Bun Cook (EV) assisted by Frank Boucher and Bill Cook
3
1
3rd period
NYR
SEN
Bun Cook (EV) assisted by Frank Boucher
4
1
Earl Roche (EV) unassisted
4
2
Bill Touhey (EV) assisted by Syd Howe
4
3