The Pittsburgh Penguins couldn't pull it off against the Philadelphia Flyers, 5 to 4, on December 23, 2005.
1st period
PHI
PIT
Simon Gagne (PP) assisted by Kim Johnsson and Sami Kapanen
1
0
Peter Forsberg (EV) assisted by Dennis Seidenberg and Mike Richards
2
0
2nd period
PHI
PIT
Dennis Seidenberg (PP) assisted by Peter Forsberg and Freddy Meyer
3
0
Tomas Surovy (EV) assisted by Sidney Crosby and Ziggy Palffy
3
1
Erik Christensen (PP) assisted by Mark Recchi and Michel Ouellet
3
2
3rd period
PHI
PIT
Sidney Crosby (EV) assisted by Ziggy Palffy and Ric Jackman
3
3
Sidney Crosby (EV) assisted by Brooks Orpik and Erik Christensen
3
4
Peter Forsberg (EV) assisted by R.J. Umberger and Derian Hatcher
4
4
Mike Knuble (EV) assisted by Mike Richards and Simon Gagne
5
4