The Chicago Black Hawks couldn't pull it off against the Toronto Maple Leafs, 4 to 3, on December 25, 1968.

Paul Henderson (EV) assisted by Pierre Pilote and Norm Ullman

1

0

Dennis Hull (PP) assisted by Stan Mikita and Kenny Wharram

1

1

Larry Mickey (EV) assisted by Paul Henderson and Norm Ullman

2

1

Ron Ellis (EV) assisted by Mike Pelyk and Norm Ullman

3

1

Pit Martin (EV) assisted by Jim Pappin

3

2

Pat Stapleton (EV) assisted by Jim Pappin

3

3

Paul Henderson (EV) assisted by Pat Quinn and Norm Ullman

4

3