The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the Detroit Red Wings, 3 to 2, on December 7, 1944.
1st period
DET
NYR
Murray Armstrong (EV) unassisted
1
0
Ott Heller (EV) assisted by Ab DeMarco Sr. and Joe Shack
1
1
2nd period
DET
NYR
Carl Liscombe (EV) assisted by Harold Jackson
2
1
Mud Bruneteau (EV) unassisted
3
1
3rd period
DET
NYR
Grant Warwick (EV) assisted by Phil Watson and Chuck Scherza
3
2