The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the New York Americans, 5 to 4, on February 14, 1937.
1st period
NYA
NYR
Art Chapman (EV) assisted by Sweeney Schriner and Lorne Carr
1
0
Tom Anderson (EV) assisted by Lorne Carr
2
0
2nd period
NYA
NYR
Eddie Wiseman (EV) assisted by Art Chapman
3
0
Butch Keeling (EV) assisted by Murray Murdoch and Ott Heller
3
1
Joe Jerwa (EV) assisted by Sweeney Schriner and Eddie Wiseman
4
1
3rd period
NYA
NYR
Lorne Carr (EV) assisted by Tom Anderson and Tony Hemmerling
5
1
Babe Pratt (EV) assisted by Mac Colville
5
2
Butch Keeling (EV) assisted by Phil Watson and Frank Boucher
5
3
Babe Pratt (EV) unassisted
5
4