The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the Montreal Canadiens, 5 to 4, on February 17, 1946.
1st period
MTL
NYR
Glen Harmon (EV) assisted by Maurice Richard and Toe Blake
1
0
Lynn Patrick (EV) assisted by Edgar Laprade
1
1
Grant Warwick (EV) assisted by Ab DeMarco Sr.
1
2
Glen Harmon (EV) unassisted
2
2
2nd period
MTL
NYR
Tony Leswick (EV) assisted by Grant Warwick
2
3
Buddy O'Connor (EV) assisted by Dutch Hiller
3
3
3rd period
MTL
NYR
Maurice Richard (EV) assisted by Elmer Lach
4
3
Ab DeMarco Sr. (EV) assisted by Hal Laycoe
4
4
Toe Blake (EV) assisted by Elmer Lach
5
4