The Toronto Arenas couldn't pull it off against the Ottawa Senators, 4 to 3, in overtime on February 18, 1919.

Reg Noble assisted by Alf Skinner

0

1

Punch Broadbent assisted by Georges Boucher

1

1

Corb Denneny assisted by Reg Noble

1

2

Ken Randall unassisted

1

3

Frank Nighbor unassisted

2

3

Sprague Cleghorn assisted by Frank Nighbor

3

3

Punch Broadbent assisted by Frank Nighbor

4

3