The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the Chicago Black Hawks, 2 to 1, on February 18, 1934.
3rd period
CHI
NYR
Johnny Gottselig (PP) assisted by Rosie Couture and Johnny Sheppard
1
0
Paul Thompson (EV) assisted by Doc Romnes and Lionel Conacher
2
0
Earl Seibert (EV) assisted by Cecil Dillon and Vic Ripley
2
1