The Toronto Maple Leafs couldn't pull it off against the Ottawa Senators, 2 to 1, on February 19, 1931.
1st period
SEN
TOR
Hec Kilrea assisted by Danny Cox and Joe Lamb
1
0
2nd period
SEN
TOR
Charlie Conacher unassisted
1
1
3rd period
SEN
TOR
Alex Smith assisted by Art Gagne and Bill Touhey
2
1