The Pittsburgh Pirates couldn't pull it off against the Montreal Maroons, 5 to 4, on February 22, 1930.
1st period
MMR
PIR
Dunc Munro unassisted
1
0
Gerry Lowrey assisted by John McKinnon and Harold Darragh
1
1
Jimmy Ward assisted by Bill Phillips
2
1
2nd period
MMR
PIR
Nels Stewart unassisted
3
1
Cliff Barton assisted by James Jarvis
3
2
3rd period
MMR
PIR
Harold Darragh assisted by Gerry Lowrey
3
3
Nels Stewart assisted by Babe Siebert
4
3
Hooley Smith assisted by Nels Stewart
5
3
Harold Darragh assisted by Gord Fraser
5
4