The Montreal Maroons couldn't pull it off against the Toronto Maple Leafs, 2 to 1, in overtime on February 27, 1934.
2nd period
TOR
MMR
Jimmy Ward (EV) assisted by Russ Blinco
0
1
3rd period
TOR
MMR
King Clancy (EV) assisted by Ken Doraty
1
1
OT
TOR
MMR
Bill Thoms (EV) unassisted
2
1