1st period
TOR
NYR
Bob Davidson (EV) assisted by Mel Hill and Wally Stanowski
1
0
Bill Moe (EV) assisted by Edgar Laprade
1
1
Edgar Laprade (EV) assisted by Alf Pike and Phil Watson
1
2
Grant Warwick (EV) assisted by Ab DeMarco Sr.
1
3
Tony Leswick (EV) assisted by Grant Warwick and Ab DeMarco Sr.
1
4
Billy Taylor Sr. (EV) assisted by Gaye Stewart
2
4
2nd period
TOR
NYR
Ab DeMarco Sr. (EV) assisted by Grant Warwick
2
5
Billy Taylor Sr. (EV) assisted by Gaye Stewart
3
5
Billy Taylor Sr. (EV) assisted by Gus Bodnar
4
5
3rd period
TOR
NYR
Jack Hamilton (EV) assisted by Bob Davidson
5
5
Edgar Laprade (EV) assisted by Mac Colville
5
6
Gus Bodnar (EV) assisted by Gaye Stewart
6
6