The Ottawa Senators couldn't pull it off against the Toronto St. Patricks, 4 to 3, on February 7, 1920.
1st period
TSP
SEN
Punch Broadbent assisted by Frank Nighbor
0
1
Cully Wilson unassisted
1
1
2nd period
TSP
SEN
Reg Noble unassisted
2
1
Reg Noble unassisted
3
1
3rd period
TSP
SEN
Corb Denneny unassisted
4
1
Frank Nighbor assisted by Georges Boucher
4
2
Frank Nighbor unassisted
4
3