The Toronto Maple Leafs couldn't pull it off against the New York Rangers, 5 to 4, on March 1, 1958.

Final

NYR

Rangers

27-23-10

5

TOR

Maple Leafs

19-30-10

4

Team

NYR

TOR

1

3

1

2

0

3

3

2

0

Total

5

4

Summary

Team Stats

Player Stats

1st period

NYR

TOR

Rangers

Camille Henry (PP) assisted by Dave Creighton and Andy Hebenton

1

0

Rangers

Andy Bathgate (EV) assisted by Dave Creighton

2

0

Maple Leafs

Bob Pulford (EV) assisted by Barry Cullen and Ron Stewart

2

1

Rangers

Camille Henry (EV) assisted by Dave Creighton and Harry Howell

3

1

2nd period

NYR

TOR

Maple Leafs

Ron Stewart (PP) assisted by Bob Pulford and Brian Cullen

3

2

Maple Leafs

Dick Duff (EV) assisted by Gary Aldcorn

3

3

Maple Leafs

Bob Pulford (PP) assisted by Brian Cullen

3

4

3rd period

NYR

TOR

Rangers

Larry Popein (EV) assisted by Danny Lewicki and Bill Gadsby

4

4

Rangers

Danny Lewicki (EV) assisted by Larry Popein and Jean-Guy Gendron

5

4