The Pittsburgh Penguins couldn't pull it off against the New York Rangers, 5 to 4, on March 10, 1973.
1st period
NYR
PIT
Gene Carr (EV) assisted by Walt Tkaczuk and Brad Park
1
0
Steve Vickers (EV) assisted by Rod Gilbert and Jean Ratelle
2
0
Jean Ratelle (EV) assisted by Rod Gilbert and Steve Vickers
3
0
Syl Apps Jr. (PP) assisted by Eddie Shack and Darryl Edestrand
3
1
Walt Tkaczuk (EV) assisted by Rod Seiling and Gene Carr
4
1
2nd period
NYR
PIT
Darryl Edestrand (EV) assisted by Syl Apps Jr. and Bryan Watson
4
2
Greg Polis (EV) assisted by Al McDonough and Ron Schock
4
3
3rd period
NYR
PIT
Brad Park (EV) assisted by Walt Tkaczuk and Bill Fairbairn
5
3
Eddie Shack (EV) unassisted
5
4