The Toronto Maple Leafs couldn't pull it off against the Montreal Maroons, 6 to 5, on March 5, 1931.

Lionel Conacher unassisted

1

0

Jimmy Ward assisted by Dave Trottier

2

0

Baldy Northcott assisted by Hooley Smith

3

0

Hooley Smith unassisted

4

0

Baldy Cotton assisted by Hap Day

4

1

Nels Stewart assisted by Babe Siebert

5

1

Charlie Conacher assisted by Joe Primeau

5

2

Ace Bailey assisted by Baldy Cotton and Bob Gracie

5

3

Baldy Northcott assisted by Jack McVicar

6

3

Baldy Cotton assisted by Ace Bailey and Andy Blair

6

4

Baldy Cotton assisted by Ace Bailey

6

5