The New York Islanders couldn't pull it off against the Pittsburgh Penguins, 2 to 1, on March 5, 1974.
1st period
PIT
NYI
Jean Pronovost (EV) assisted by Syl Apps Jr. and Lowell MacDonald
1
0
2nd period
PIT
NYI
Ralph Stewart (EV) unassisted
1
1
3rd period
PIT
NYI
Syl Apps Jr. (PP) assisted by Lowell MacDonald and Jean Pronovost
2
1