The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the Ottawa Senators, 5 to 4, in overtime on March 6, 1934.
1st period
SEN
NYR
Bill Touhey (EV) assisted by Carl Voss
1
0
Bun Cook (EV) assisted by Ott Heller
1
1
Nick Wasnie (EV) assisted by Bill Touhey
2
1
2nd period
SEN
NYR
Vic Ripley (EV) assisted by Cecil Dillon and Murray Murdoch
2
2
3rd period
SEN
NYR
Nick Wasnie (EV) assisted by Walter Kalbfleish and Bill Touhey
3
2
Murray Murdoch (EV) assisted by Cecil Dillon and Vic Ripley
3
3
OT
SEN
NYR
Butch Keeling (EV) assisted by Frank Boucher and Ott Heller
3
4
Nick Wasnie (PP) assisted by Des Roche and Flash Hollett
4
4
Bill Touhey (EV) assisted by Nick Wasnie and Carl Voss
5
4