The Pittsburgh Penguins couldn't pull it off against the Tampa Bay Lightning, 5 to 4, in a shootout on March 7, 2006.
1st period
TBL
PIT
Dan Boyle (EV) assisted by Martin Cibak and Darren Reid
1
0
2nd period
TBL
PIT
Ryan Malone (PP) assisted by Ryan Whitney
1
1
Dmitry Afanasenkov (EV) assisted by Ryan Craig
2
1
Fredrik Modin (EV) assisted by Martin St. Louis and Dan Boyle
3
1
3rd period
TBL
PIT
Dan Boyle (PP) assisted by Vincent Lecavalier and Brad Richards
4
1
Sidney Crosby (PP) assisted by Sergei Gonchar and John LeClair
4
2
Josef Melichar (EV) assisted by Sidney Crosby and Mark Recchi
4
3
Ryan Whitney (EV) assisted by Sergei Gonchar and Colby Armstrong
4
4