The Pittsburgh Pirates couldn't pull it off against the Chicago Black Hawks, 4 to 3, on March 8, 1930.
1st period
CHI
PIR
Clarence Abel unassisted
1
0
2nd period
CHI
PIR
Cliff Barton unassisted
1
1
Gord Fraser assisted by Harold Darragh
1
2
Johnny Gottselig assisted by Duke Dukowski
2
2
Rosie Couture unassisted
3
2
3rd period
CHI
PIR
Tom Cook unassisted
4
2
Jesse Spring assisted by Hib Milks
4
3