The New York Islanders couldn't pull it off against the Pittsburgh Penguins, 6 to 5, in overtime on April 11, 2010.
1st period
PIT
NYI
Evgeni Malkin (EV) assisted by Alex Goligoski and Sidney Crosby
1
0
Eric Godard (EV) assisted by Sidney Crosby and Sergei Gonchar
2
0
Sidney Crosby (EV) assisted by Evgeni Malkin and Pascal Dupuis
3
0
John Tavares (PP) assisted by Mark Streit and Kyle Okposo
3
1
2nd period
PIT
NYI
Sidney Crosby (EV) assisted by Max Talbot
4
1
Matt Moulson (PP) assisted by Mark Streit and Frans Nielsen
4
2
Evgeni Malkin (PP) assisted by Sidney Crosby and Alex Goligoski
5
2
3rd period
PIT
NYI
Kyle Okposo (EV) assisted by Mark Streit and John Tavares
5
3
Jon Sim (EV) assisted by Trent Hunter and Jack Hillen
5
4
John Tavares (EV) assisted by Freddy Meyer and Kyle Okposo
5
5
OT
PIT
NYI
Jordan Leopold (EV) assisted by Evgeni Malkin and Mark Eaton
6
5