The Pittsburgh Penguins couldn't pull it off against the New Jersey Devils, 3 to 2, in overtime on April 2, 2006.
1st period
NJD
PIT
Sidney Crosby (PP) assisted by Sergei Gonchar and Ryan Whitney
0
1
Colby Armstrong (EV) assisted by Sidney Crosby and Ryan Whitney
0
2
2nd period
NJD
PIT
Jay Pandolfo (EV) assisted by Paul Martin and John Madden
1
2
3rd period
NJD
PIT
Patrik Elias (PP) assisted by Brian Gionta and Brian Rafalski
2
2
OT
NJD
PIT
Brian Gionta (EV) assisted by Sergei Brylin
3
2