Cap Anson was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1939.

	NAME	HOF	G	W	L	W%	GS	ERA	SO	CG	SHO	SV	IP	H	ER	R	HR	BB	HBP	GF	TBF	WP	K/9	BB/9	K/BB	HR/9	K%	BB%	WHIP	BABIP	RA	ERA-	FIP	FIP-	H/9	PRAA
1	Cap Anson C. Anson	1939	3	0	1	.000	0	4.50	1	0	0	1	4.0	4	2	5	2	2		3	21	0	2.25	4.50	0.50	4.50	4.8	9.5	1.50		11.25	143	10.76	306	9.00	-3
2	Jim O'Rourke J. O'Rourke	1945	6	0	1	.000	0	4.12	4	0	0	2	19.2	17	9	14	0	2		3	70	1	1.83	0.92	2.00	0.00	5.7	2.9	0.97		6.41	131	3.16	93	7.78	0.7
3	Deacon White D. White	2013	2	0	0		0	7.20	3	0	0	1	10.0	19	8	15	0	2		2	51	0	2.70	1.80	1.50	0.00	5.9	3.9	2.10	.413	13.50	174	2.78	65	17.10	1.1
4	King Kelly K. Kelly	1945	12	2	2	.500	0	4.14	4	0	0	0	45.2	63	21	49	5	30		9	236	8	0.79	5.91	0.13	0.99	1.7	12.7	2.04	.301	9.66	112	6.33	169	12.42	-12.6
5	John Ward J. Ward	1964	293	164	103	.614	262	2.10	920	245	24	3	2469.2	2,324	576	1,185	26	253		32	10,164	144	3.35	0.92	3.64	0.09	9.1	2.5	1.04		4.32	82	2.43	96	8.47	9.1
6	Dan Brouthers D. Brouthers	1945	4	0	2	.000	2	7.83	8	2	0	0	23.0	44	20	37	0	11		1	127	4	3.13	4.30	0.73	0.00	6.3	8.7	2.39		14.48	291	3.52	138	17.22	-2.6
7	Pud Galvin P. Galvin	1965	697	361	308	.540	681	2.87	1,799	639	57	1	5941.1	6,352	1,895	3,315	121	744	54	18	25,160	220	2.73	1.13	2.42	0.18	7.2	3.0	1.19	.278	5.02	94	2.97	95	9.62	94.5
8	Roger Connor R. Connor	1976
9	Buck Ewing B. Ewing	1939	9	2	3	.400	4	3.45	23	4	0	0	47.0	55	18	36	2	23		4	233	3	4.40	4.40	1.00	0.38	9.9	9.9	1.66	.288	6.89	95	4.07	114	10.53	-1.8
10	Tim Keefe T. Keefe	1964	600	342	225	.603	594	2.63	2,564	554	39	2	5049.2	4,438	1,474	2,470	75	1,233	83	7	20,941	240	4.57	2.20	2.08	0.13	12.2	5.9	1.12	.257	4.40	79	2.92	87	7.91	239.2
11	Old Hoss Radbourn O. Hoss Radbourn	1939	527	309	194	.614	502	2.68	1,830	488	35	3	4527.1	4,328	1,347	2,273	118	875	54	24	18,918	214	3.64	1.74	2.09	0.23	9.7	4.6	1.15	.262	4.52	82	3.15	95	8.60	51
12	Mickey Welch M. Welch	1973	565	307	210	.594	549	2.71	1,850	525	41	4	4802.0	4,588	1,447	2,556	106	1,297	52	16	20,308	274	3.47	2.43	1.43	0.20	9.1	6.4	1.23	.264	4.79	88	3.28	103	8.60	-55.7
13	John Clarkson J. Clarkson	1963	531	328	178	.648	518	2.81	1,978	485	37	5	4536.1	4,295	1,417	2,384	159	1,191	80	12	19,146	182	3.92	2.36	1.66	0.32	10.3	6.2	1.21	.263	4.73	75	3.35	88	8.52	289.8
14	Bid McPhee B. McPhee	2000
15	Tommy McCarthy T. McCarthy	1946	13	0	8	.000	7	4.99	21	5	0	0	70.1	85	39	65	3	26		7	323	12	2.69	3.33	0.81	0.38	6.5	8.0	1.58	.300	8.32	157	4.27	148	10.88	-10.7
16	Sam Thompson S. Thompson	1974
17	Jake Beckley J. Beckley	1971	1	0	1	.000	1	6.75	2	0	0	0	4.0	9	3	8	0	1	0	0	21	0	4.50	2.25	2.00	0.00	9.5	4.8	2.50	.500	18.00	223	2.42	76	20.25	0.4
18	Ed Delahanty E. Delahanty	1945
19	Hugh Duffy H. Duffy	1945
20	Billy Hamilton B. Hamilton	1961
21	Amos Rusie A. Rusie	1977	463	246	174	.586	427	3.07	1,950	393	30	5	3778.2	3,389	1,288	2,068	75	1,707	112	35	16,313	153	4.64	4.07	1.14	0.18	12.0	10.5	1.35	.266	4.93	78	3.71	92	8.07	124.3
22	Jesse Burkett J. Burkett	1946	23	3	11	.214	14	5.56	84	6	0	0	123.0	144	76	129	3	94	14	8	617	16	6.15	6.88	0.89	0.22	13.6	15.2	1.93	.334	9.44	156	4.53	119	10.54	-10
23	George Davis G. Davis	1998	3	0	1	.000	0	15.75	4	0	0	1	4.0	8	7	8	0	3	0	3	23	0	9.00	6.75	1.33	0.00	17.4	13.0	2.75	.500	18.00	457	2.78	78	18.00	0.4
24	Kid Nichols K. Nichols	1949	621	361	208	.634	562	2.96	1,881	532	48	17	5067.1	4,929	1,664	2,480	156	1,272	129	56	21,082	169	3.34	2.26	1.48	0.28	8.9	6.0	1.22	.271	4.40	73	3.48	85	8.75	377.8
25	Cy Young C. Young	1937	906	511	316	.618	815	2.63	2,803	749	76	17	7356.0	7,092	2,147	3,167	138	1,217	161	84	29,565	156	3.43	1.49	2.30	0.17	9.5	4.1	1.13	.275	3.87	74	2.84	79	8.68	620