Don Mattingly has gotten the most hits by a Yankees first baseman in a season, with 238 hits in 1986.

	NAME	H	SEASON	TM	G	AB	R	2B	3B	HR	RBI	BB	HBP	SO	SB	CS	PA	TB	XBH	SH	SF	IBB	GIDP	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	WRC	WRAA	WOBA	WRC+	BRAA
1	Don Mattingly D. Mattingly	238	1986	NYY	162	677	117	53	2	31	113	53	1	35	0	0	742	388	86	1	10	11	17	.352	.394	.573	.967	141	55.9	.416	160	54.2
2	Lou Gehrig L. Gehrig	220	1930	NYY	154	581	143	42	17	41	173	101	3	63	12	14	703	419	100	18				.379	.473	.721	1.194	193	94.5	.507	198	98.3
3	Lou Gehrig L. Gehrig	218	1927	NYY	155	584	149	52	18	47	173	109	3	84	10	8	717	447	117	21				.373	.474	.765	1.240	199	110.9	.540	209	105.6
4	Don Mattingly D. Mattingly	211	1985	NYY	159	652	107	48	3	35	145	56	2	41	2	2	727	370	86	2	15	13	15	.324	.371	.567	.939	129	46.9	.400	152	44.9
5	Lou Gehrig L. Gehrig	211	1931	NYY	155	619	163	31	15	46	185	117	0	56	17	12	738	410	92	2				.341	.446	.662	1.108	179	87.7	.488	184	83.8
6	Lou Gehrig L. Gehrig	210	1934	NYY	154	579	128	40	6	49	166	109	2	31	9	5	690	409	95	0				.363	.465	.706	1.172	182	94.8	.511	194	90.9
7	Lou Gehrig L. Gehrig	210	1928	NYY	154	562	139	47	13	27	147	95	4	69	4	11	677	364	87	16				.374	.467	.648	1.115	165	82.1	.496	192	80.9
8	Lou Gehrig L. Gehrig	208	1932	NYY	156	596	138	42	9	34	151	108	3	38	4	11	708	370	85	1				.349	.451	.621	1.072	167	77.9	.472	174	73.4
9	Don Mattingly D. Mattingly	207	1984	NYY	153	603	91	44	2	23	110	41	1	33	1	1	662	324	69	8	9	8	15	.343	.381	.537	.918	116	42.4	.401	153	41
10	Lou Gehrig L. Gehrig	205	1936	NYY	155	579	167	37	7	49	152	130	7	46	3	4	719	403	93	3				.354	.478	.696	1.174	192	97.6	.512	178	85.8
11	Lou Gehrig L. Gehrig	200	1937	NYY	157	569	138	37	9	37	158	127	4	49	4	3	700	366	83	0				.351	.473	.643	1.116	173	85.5	.494	176	76.5
12	Lou Gehrig L. Gehrig	198	1933	NYY	152	593	138	41	12	32	140	92	1	42	9	13	687	359	85	1				.334	.424	.605	1.030	149	69.6	.462	168	62.5
13	Hal Chase H. Chase	193	1906	NYH	151	597	84	23	10	0	76	13	3	48	28		637	236	33	24				.323	.341	.395	.736	83	20.4	.355	118	12.1
14	Don Mattingly D. Mattingly	191	1989	NYY	158	631	79	37	2	23	113	51	1	30	3	0	693	301	62	0	10	18	15	.303	.351	.477	.828	100	24.4	.360	127	21.4
15	Wally Pipp W. Pipp	190	1922	NYY	152	577	96	32	10	9	94	56	4	32	7	12	664	269	51	27				.329	.392	.466	.859	109	25.4	.396	123	20.5
16	Chris Chambliss C. Chambliss	188	1976	NYY	156	641	79	32	6	17	96	27	3	80	1	0	675	283	55	1	3	1	11	.293	.323	.441	.765	88	17.1	.350	126	18.3
17	Don Mattingly D. Mattingly	186	1988	NYY	144	599	94	37	0	18	88	41	3	29	1	0	651	277	55	0	8	14	13	.311	.353	.462	.816	93	21.7	.356	123	17.3
18	Don Mattingly D. Mattingly	186	1987	NYY	141	569	93	38	2	30	115	51	1	38	1	4	629	318	70	0	8	13	16	.327	.378	.559	.937	113	35.6	.394	142	33.5
19	Don Mattingly D. Mattingly	184	1992	NYY	157	640	89	40	0	14	86	39	1	43	3	0	686	266	54	0	6	7	11	.288	.327	.416	.742	82	7.4	.331	107	5.6
20	Lou Gehrig L. Gehrig	179	1926	NYY	155	572	135	47	20	16	109	105	1	73	6	5	696	314	83	18				.313	.420	.549	.969	136	52.6	.441	151	47.3
21	Mark Teixeira M. Teixeira	178	2009	NYY	156	609	103	43	3	39	122	81	12	114	2	0	707	344	85	0	5	9	13	.292	.383	.565	.948	128	43	.402	142	36.8
22	Jason Giambi J. Giambi	176	2002	NYY	155	560	120	34	1	41	122	109	15	112	2	2	689	335	76	0	5	4	18	.314	.435	.598	1.034	148	64.8	.440	175	63.6
23	Tino Martinez T. Martinez	176	1997	NYY	158	594	96	31	2	44	141	75	3	75	3	1	685	343	77	0	13	14	15	.296	.371	.577	.948	121	36.3	.396	141	35.8
24	Lou Gehrig L. Gehrig	176	1935	NYY	149	535	125	26	10	30	120	132	5	38	8	7	672	312	66	0				.329	.466	.583	1.049	154	70.5	.471	171	66.2
25	Danny Cater D. Cater	175	1970	NYY	155	582	64	26	5	6	76	34	2	44	4	2	621	229	37	1	2	6	19	.301	.340	.393	.734	74	4.2	.328	106	4.5