Dan Brouthers and Hardy Richardson were tied for the most home runs in 1886, with 11 home runs.

	NAME	HR	SEASON	TM	G	AB	R	H	2B	3B	RBI	BB	HBP	SO	SB	PA	TB	XBH	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	WRC	WRAA	WOBA	WRC+	BRAA
1	Dan Brouthers D. Brouthers	11	1886	DET	121	489	139	181	40	15	72	66		16	21	555	284	66	.370		.581		153	72.2	.469	180	68
2	Hardy Richardson H. Richardson	11	1886	DET	125	538	125	189	27	11	61	46		27	42	584	271	49	.351		.504		139	53.4	.420	155	49
3	Cap Anson C. Anson	10	1886	CWS	125	504	117	187	35	11	147	55		19	29	559	274	56	.371		.544		146	64.6	.451	164	54.6
4	Jerry Denny J. Denny	9	1886	SLN	119	475	58	122	24	6	62	14		68	16	489	185	39	.257		.389		73	1.9	.307	100	0.3
5	Paul Hines P. Hines	9	1886	WSH	121	487	80	152	30	8	56	35		21	21	522	225	47	.312		.462		108	31.6	.380	138	30.7
6	Alex McKinnon A. McKinnon	8	1886	SLN	122	491	75	148	24	7	72	21		23	10	512	210	39	.301		.428		94	19.5	.351	123	17.9
7	Bid McPhee B. McPhee	8	1886	CIN	140	560	139	150	23	12	70	59	5		40	624	221	43	.268	.343	.395	.738	114	22.4	.349	122	20.2
8	Sam Thompson S. Thompson	8	1886	DET	122	503	101	156	18	13	89	35		31	13	538	224	39	.310		.445		108	29.1	.372	130	25
9	Roger Connor R. Connor	7	1886	NYG	118	485	105	172	29	20	71	41		15	17	526	262	56	.355		.540		131	53.7	.433	164	52
10	Fred Dunlap F. Dunlap	7	1886	TOT	122	481	85	132	23	5	69	44		51	20	525	186	35	.274		.387		92	15.7	.341	116	13.1
11	John Morrill J. Morrill	7	1886	BSN	117	430	86	106	25	6	69	56		81	9	486	164	38	.247		.381		85	13.9	.339	116	11.6
12	Dave Orr D. Orr	7	1886	NYM	136	571	93	193	25	31	91	17	5		16	593	301	63	.338	.363	.527	.890	134	47.5	.405	155	48
13	Fred Pfeffer F. Pfeffer	7	1886	CWS	118	474	88	125	17	8	95	36		46	30	510	179	32	.264		.378		84	9.3	.326	100	0.2
14	Harry Stovey H. Stovey	7	1886	PHA	123	489	115	144	28	11	59	64	1		68	554	215	46	.294	.377	.440	.817	116	35	.384	138	31.4
15	Frank Fennelly F. Fennelly	6	1886	CIN	132	497	113	124	13	17	72	60	18		32	575	189	36	.249	.351	.380	.732	105	21.3	.350	123	19.2
16	George Gore G. Gore	6	1886	CWS	118	444	150	135	20	12	63	102		30	23	546	197	38	.304		.444		129	49.2	.418	147	39.4
17	Charley Jones C. Jones	6	1886	CIN	127	500	87	135	22	10	68	61	6		3	567	195	38	.270	.356	.390	.746	106	23.3	.355	125	21.3
18	John Reilly J. Reilly	6	1886	CIN	115	441	92	117	12	11	79	31	5		19	477	169	29	.265	.321	.383	.704	80	10.6	.331	113	8.9
19	Jack Rowe J. Rowe	6	1886	DET	111	468	97	142	21	9	87	26		27	12	494	199	36	.303		.425		93	20.7	.356	122	16.9
20	Ned Williamson N. Williamson	6	1886	CWS	121	430	69	93	17	8	58	80		71	13	510	144	31	.216		.335		85	10.5	.329	102	1.4
21	Fred Carroll F. Carroll	5	1886	PIT	122	486	92	140	28	11	64	52	4		20	542	205	44	.288	.362	.422	.783	107	27.9	.369	139	31.5
22	Pop Corkhill P. Corkhill	5	1886	CIN	129	540	81	143	9	7	97	23	6		24	569	181	21	.265	.302	.335	.637	83	0	.303	98	-2.1
23	Sid Farrar S. Farrar	5	1886	PHN	118	439	55	109	19	7	50	16		47	10	455	157	31	.248		.358		63	-3.1	.294	93	-5.2
24	Jocko Milligan J. Milligan	5	1886	PHA	75	301	52	76	17	3	45	21	0		18	322	114	25	.252	.301	.379	.680	51	3.9	.318	104	1.8
25	Chief Roseman C. Roseman	5	1886	NYM	134	559	90	127	19	10	53	24	8		6	591	181	34	.227	.269	.324	.593	76	-10.5	.280	88	-10.1