Between the 1883 and 1892 seasons, Tim Keefe fanned the most hitters, with 2,255 strikeouts.

	NAME	SO	G	W	L	W%	GS	ERA	CG	SHO	SV	IP	H	ER	R	HR	BB	HBP	GF	TBF	WP	K/9	BB/9	K/BB	HR/9	K%	BB%	WHIP	BABIP	RA	ERA-	FIP	FIP-	H/9	PRAA
1	Tim Keefe T. Keefe	2,255	478	291	159	.647	473	2.55	439	34	2	3987.2	3,367	1,128	1,850	64	976	70	6	16,441	215	5.09	2.20	2.31	0.14	13.7	5.9	1.09	.253	4.18	75	2.87	83	7.60	238.5
2	John Clarkson J. Clarkson	1,885	470	303	149	.670	462	2.62	439	36	5	4066.2	3,715	1,185	2,004	142	1,048	75	8	17,035	156	4.17	2.32	1.80	0.31	11.1	6.2	1.17	.257	4.44	74	3.23	87	8.22	260.7
3	Charlie Buffinton C. Buffinton	1,683	409	231	149	.608	391	2.95	347	29	3	3362.0	3,291	1,101	1,790	85	842	31	17	14,272	172	4.51	2.25	2.00	0.23	11.8	5.9	1.23	.276	4.79	87	3.07	88	8.81	158
4	Mickey Welch M. Welch	1,570	427	238	146	.620	412	2.69	391	28	4	3579.0	3,308	1,068	1,828	85	1,077	52	15	15,131	222	3.95	2.71	1.46	0.21	10.4	7.1	1.23	.261	4.60	83	3.40	101	8.32	-25.8
5	Toad Ramsey T. Ramsey	1,515	248	113	124	.477	241	3.29	225	5	0	2100.2	1,941	769	1,373	40	671	38	7	9,018	179	6.49	2.87	2.26	0.17	16.8	7.4	1.24	.282	5.88	88	2.85	78	8.32	192.8
6	Old Hoss Radbourn O. Hoss Radbourn	1,512	432	251	164	.605	415	2.77	404	26	3	3736.0	3,597	1,150	1,898	111	760	54	17	15,622	174	3.64	1.83	1.99	0.27	9.7	4.9	1.17	.264	4.57	82	3.30	96	8.67	40.2
7	Tony Mullane T. Mullane	1,485	421	228	159	.589	386	2.88	366	25	9	3504.1	3,114	1,122	1,856	77	1,024	112	36	14,827	263	3.81	2.63	1.45	0.20	10.0	6.9	1.18	.251	4.77	83	3.42	98	8.00	31.3
8	Adonis Terry A. Terry	1,298	321	144	147	.495	302	3.34	280	16	6	2625.1	2,484	974	1,582	49	847	64	19	11,289	173	4.45	2.90	1.53	0.17	11.5	7.5	1.27	.270	5.42	97	3.28	96	8.52	37
9	Mark Baldwin M. Baldwin	1,249	300	138	145	.488	288	3.27	262	12	3	2468.2	2,354	896	1,584	75	1,165	111	13	10,988	208	4.55	4.25	1.07	0.27	11.4	10.6	1.43	.272	5.77	90	3.73	101	8.58	-8.4
10	Pud Galvin P. Galvin	1,237	465	248	199	.555	457	3.00	432	38	1	3970.1	4,217	1,325	2,230	101	595	54	8	16,818	123	2.80	1.35	2.08	0.23	7.4	3.5	1.21	.278	5.05	92	3.21	95	9.56	44.4
11	Jim Whitney J. Whitney	1,229	298	136	150	.476	285	3.13	274	17	2	2524.0	2,646	879	1,513	70	280	28	12	10,622	139	4.38	1.00	4.39	0.25	11.6	2.6	1.16	.286	5.40	98	2.83	85	9.44	132.1
12	Ed Morris E. Morris	1,217	311	171	122	.584	307	2.82	297	29	1	2678.0	2,468	838	1,312	42	498	25	4	11,073	112	4.09	1.67	2.44	0.14	11.0	4.5	1.11	.262	4.41	87	2.91	92	8.29	34.1
13	Gus Weyhing G. Weyhing	1,208	316	177	124	.588	301	3.16	283	21	3	2629.0	2,419	923	1,505	62	998	179	15	11,429	203	4.14	3.42	1.21	0.21	10.6	8.7	1.30	.262	5.15	83	3.52	96	8.28	50.3
14	Matt Kilroy M. Kilroy	1,137	277	132	119	.526	269	3.34	246	18	1	2263.1	2,223	840	1,397	47	681	95	9	9,793	194	4.52	2.71	1.67	0.19	11.6	7.0	1.28	.278	5.56	92	3.34	91	8.84	68.9
15	Silver King S. King	1,112	328	179	126	.587	313	2.88	292	18	3	2727.1	2,535	872	1,452	53	797	122	13	11,604	140	3.67	2.63	1.40	0.17	9.6	6.9	1.22	.261	4.79	77	3.24	88	8.37	151.3
16	Amos Rusie A. Rusie	1,091	226	106	95	.527	203	2.99	186	13	2	1815.0	1,483	602	1,015	28	937	65	23	7,896	86	5.41	4.65	1.16	0.14	13.8	11.9	1.33	.252	5.03	86	3.33	94	7.35	39.3
17	Guy Hecker G. Hecker	1,077	323	169	140	.547	311	2.99	302	15	1	2820.0	2,847	936	1,677	50	487	28	12	12,012	121	3.44	1.55	2.21	0.16	9.0	4.1	1.18	.271	5.35	87	3.16	94	9.09	45
18	Pretzels Getzien P. Getzien	1,070	296	145	139	.511	292	3.46	277	11	1	2539.2	2,670	976	1,555	95	602	28	4	10,939	111	3.79	2.13	1.78	0.34	9.8	5.5	1.29	.282	5.51	101	3.32	93	9.46	80.7
19	Ice Box Chamberlain I. Box Chamberlain	1,015	262	131	98	.572	250	3.34	226	14	1	2092.0	1,957	776	1,245	50	857	85	11	9,115	123	4.37	3.69	1.18	0.22	11.1	9.4	1.35	.268	5.36	90	3.46	95	8.42	51.3
20	William Hutchinson W. Hutchinson	1,005	251	138	98	.585	232	2.87	223	17	4	2121.0	1,904	677	1,131	68	685	41	19	8,954	89	4.26	2.91	1.47	0.29	11.2	7.7	1.22	.257	4.80	79	3.19	85	8.08	147.2
21	Dupee Shaw D. Shaw	950	211	83	121	.407	207	3.10	196	13	0	1762.0	1,710	607	1,050	41	396	3	4	7,555	85	4.85	2.02	2.40	0.21	12.6	5.2	1.20	.271	5.36	99	3.04	96	8.73	2.4
22	Hardie Henderson H. Henderson	930	210	81	121	.401	206	3.50	197	4	0	1788.1	1,800	696	1,230	25	522	7	4	7,852	178	4.68	2.63	1.78	0.13	11.8	6.6	1.30	.281	6.19	106	3.21	98	9.06	5
23	Bob Caruthers B. Caruthers	900	340	218	99	.688	310	2.83	298	24	3	2828.2	2,678	891	1,393	59	597	70	29	11,842	129	2.86	1.90	1.51	0.19	7.6	5.0	1.16	.257	4.43	81	3.27	94	8.52	60.9
24	Bobby Mathews B. Mathews	877	172	106	61	.635	172	3.06	164	6	0	1489.2	1,492	507	903	31	215	3	0	6,356	76	5.30	1.30	4.08	0.19	13.8	3.4	1.15	.282	5.46	88	2.76	82	9.01	106.7
25	Jack Stivetts J. Stivetts	871	198	107	66	.618	170	3.02	144	11	4	1466.2	1,255	492	800	45	650	50	28	6,320	87	5.34	3.99	1.34	0.28	13.8	10.3	1.30	.257	4.91	79	3.32	89	7.70	85.4