The St. Louis Cardinals couldn't pull it off against the Cincinnati Redlegs, 5 to 4, on September 6, 1957.

Final

CIN

Redlegs

70-66

5

STL

4

1

2

0

2

0

1

3

0

0

4

0

2

5

0

1

6

3

0

7

0

0

8

0

0

9

0

0

R

5

4

H

14

11

E

1

0

Player Stats

Redlegs

Cardinals

Batters

PlayerABRHRBIHRBBSOSBCSTB
Johnny Temple 2B5020001002
Bob Thurman LF3010020001
Frank Robinson CF3121110005
George Crowe 1B4121110005
Wally Post RF5020001002
Smoky Burgess C5010000001
Don Hoak 3B4100010000
Roy McMillan SS5131000004
Don Gross P2000001000
Jerry Lynch PH1112100004
Bill Kennedy P2000001000
Totals3951453540024

Pitchers

PlayerIPHRERBBSOHR
Don Gross (W)5.0844121
Bill Kennedy (S)4.0300020
Totals9.01144141
Some of the information used here was obtained free of charge from Retrosheet.