Marcus Semien

The Mets' 10-run 12th against Washington was baseball's biggest extra inning since 1983

NOAH TRISTER, AP Baseball Writer

May 19, 2026


WASHINGTON (AP) — The New York Mets scored so many runs in the 12th that by the time the game was over, it was hard to remember how many innings it went.

“It was a really competitive ballgame the whole way through, and then we kind of broke it open there in the 12th,” infielder Brett Baty said. “The 12th, right?”

After trading leads with the Washington Nationals for 11 innings, the Mets scored 10 times in the 12th on their way to a 16-7 victory Monday night. It was the most runs by a team in an extra inning since the Texas Rangers scored 12 in the 15th in a 16-4 win over the Oakland Athletics on July 3, 1983.

The inning actually began with a sacrifice bunt, moving the automatic runner to third. That was the only batter Washington reliever Paxton Schultz retired. Carson Benge, who has the go-ahead swing in three extra-inning wins in the last six days, hit a comebacker that glanced off Schultz's glove for an RBI infield single.

A single by Bo Bichette and an intentional walk to Juan Soto loaded the bases, then Vidal Bruján popped up a safety squeeze and the bunt landed in front of a diving Schultz for another infield hit that made it 8-6.

Baty added a two-run single, Marcus Semien brought in another run with a single, and then the Nationals waved a white flag of sorts by moving Jorbit Vivas from third base to the mound to pitch.

There was a lengthy delay as umpires tried to determine if the move was legal — it was — and then the Mets went right on hitting. A.J. Ewing added an RBI single, and three batters later Benge came up again and doubled home two runs. Bichette then hit a two-run double that made it 16-6.

Bichette had gone without an extra-base hit since April 28, but he hit a solo homer in the seventh and a double in the 12th.

The Mets have won six of seven and they're 11-5 in May. They're also 6-4 in extra-inning games, having played more than any other team this season.

By the time this one was over, everyone was having a hard time remembering all the details. Baty was asked about throwing out a runner at home from first base — but the play in question happened in the 10th, an inning before he moved from third to first.

It was Mark Vientos who threw home for that force play with the bases loaded to keep the game tied. Then both teams exchanged runs in the 11th.

Washington left 19 runners on base, the most in the majors this year.

Finally the Mets took a lead the Nationals couldn't come close to matching. And after 4 hours, 8 minutes, it ended.

“Really long game, but we battled,” Baty said.

___

AP MLB: https://apnews.com/hub/mlb

More MLB News

MLB 2026 Batting Leaders

MLB 2026 Pitching Leaders

MLB Fantasy 2026

MLB 2026 Betting

MLB 2026 Standings

NL EastWLPCTGB
57
41
.582
55
45
.550
3.0
52
48
.520
6.0
50
50
.500
8.0
42
58
.420
16.0
NL CentralWLPCTGB
62
37
.626
56
43
.566
6.0
51
47
.520
10.5
52
48
.520
10.5
45
53
.459
16.5
NL WestWLPCTGB
63
37
.630
51
48
.515
11.5
49
50
.495
13.5
42
57
.424
20.5
40
61
.396
23.5
AL EastWLPCTGB
56
42
.571
55
44
.556
1.5
50
48
.510
6.0
49
51
.490
8.0
46
53
.465
10.5
AL CentralWLPCTGB
52
46
.531
52
48
.520
1.0
49
51
.490
4.0
46
53
.465
6.5
40
60
.400
13.0
AL WestWLPCTGB
50
49
.505
50
50
.500
0.5
47
54
.465
4.0
42
57
.424
8.0
39
61
.390
11.5

MLB 2026 Scores & Schedule

Scores

DATEMATCHUPSCORE
Wed
7/1
@
6-2
Wed
7/1
@
3-23
Wed
7/1
@
3-9
Wed
7/1
@
4-0
Wed
7/1
@
2-4

Schedule

DATEMATCHUPTIME (ET)
Mon
7/20
@
6:40 PM
Mon
7/20
@
7:05 PM
Mon
7/20
@
7:07 PM
Mon
7/20
@
7:10 PM
Mon
7/20
@
7:10 PM