Mick Vukota has the most career penalty minutes for the Islanders, with 1,879 minutes in the box.

	NAME	PIM	GP	G	A	P	+/-	PPG	PPA	SHG	SHA	GWG	OTG	S	S%	FOW	FO	FOW%	HIT	BKS	TKA	GVA	TOI/GP
1	Mick Vukota M. Vukota	1,879	509	16	29	45	-31	0	1	0	0	0	0	246	6.5
2	Rich Pilon R. Pilon	1,525	509	6	54	60	-45	0	3	0	0	0	0	251	2.4	0	0		22	17	3	5	16:21
3	Garry Howatt G. Howatt	1,466	596	93	120	213	+75	2	2	0	0	12		669	13.9
4	Denis Potvin D. Potvin	1,356	1,060	310	742	1,052	+456	127	332	10	22	44	0	3,050	10.2
5	Bobby Nystrom B. Nystrom	1,248	900	235	278	513	+110	27	22	0	0	38	0	1,823	12.9
6	Matt Martin M. Martin	995	855	73	84	157	-40	2	3	0	3	13	0	955	7.6	79	204	38.7	3,489	423	202	209	11:05
7	Duane Sutter D. Sutter	893	547	121	171	292	+36	14	23	0	0	8	0	948	12.8
8	Clark Gillies C. Gillies	891	872	304	359	663	+244	92	104	0	0	41	0	2,124	14.3
9	Eric Cairns E. Cairns	814	327	9	27	36	-36	0	0	0	3	1	0	167	5.4	0	1	0.0	482	226	55	158	13:36
10	Bryan Trottier B. Trottier	798	1,123	500	853	1,353	+467	158	257	17	18	69	1	2,626	19.0
11	Gerry Hart G. Hart	783	476	20	108	128	+132	0	2	2	3	3		626	3.2
12	Brent Sutter B. Sutter	761	694	287	323	610	+120	90	86	12	5	37	1	1,661	17.3
13	Alan Kerr A. Kerr	691	326	69	85	154	+8	13	13	1	0	8	1	595	11.6
14	Ken Baumgartner K. Baumgartner	678	175	1	12	13	-18	0	0	0	0	0	0	93	1.1
15	Patrick Flatley P. Flatley	660	712	160	328	488	+57	42	55	6	7	21	2	1,309	12.2
16	Gord Lane G. Lane	614	304	9	51	60	+48	0	0	1	2	2	0	242	3.7
17	Gerald Diduck G. Diduck	580	314	26	63	89	+38	11	21	0	0	1	0	474	5.5
18	Stefan Persson S. Persson	574	622	52	317	369	+176	30	182	0	3	7	1	786	6.6
19	Bob Bourne B. Bourne	542	814	238	304	542	+162	38	52	16	12	37	1	1,573	15.1
20	Steve Webb S. Webb	530	316	5	13	18	-31	1	1	0	0	0	0	138	3.6	1	3	33.3	526	33	31	34	6:30
21	Dave Scatchard D. Scatchard	504	347	81	87	168	+8	13	8	3	2	13	0	672	12.1	2,707	5,019	53.9	655	104	125	122	14:49
22	Anders Lee A. Lee	502	841	289	218	507	+21	78	48	0	0	43	1	2,119	13.6	372	786	47.3	1,415	430	245	342	16:21
23	John Tonelli J. Tonelli	473	594	206	338	544	+215	35	72	3	2	29	1	1,108	18.6
24	Billy Smith B. Smith	470	674	1	12	13																	56:29
25	Bryan McCabe B. McCabe	466	220	18	45	63	-17	6	15	1	0	3	1	328	5.5