Brian Elliott has the most career overtime losses by a goalie versus the Islanders, with 9 losses.

most regular-season otl vs islanders by a goaltender

	NAME	OTL	GP	GS	W	L	T	SA	SV	SV%	GA	GAA	SHO	MIN
1	Brian Elliott B. Elliott	9	24	23	10	3	0	702	639	.910	63	2.70	0	1400
2	Henrik Lundqvist H. Lundqvist	7	61	59	30	21	0	1,656	1,515	.915	141	2.41	5	3509
3	Cam Ward C. Ward	5	37	36	24	5	0	1,060	966	.911	94	2.66	1	2122
4	Marc-Andre Fleury M. Fleury	5	49	47	29	12	1	1,396	1,283	.919	113	2.38	6	2848
5	Martin Brodeur M. Brodeur	5	91	76	52	28	4	2,217	2,022	.912	195	2.22	10	5274
6	Sam Montembeault S. Montembeault	4	11	10	4	2	0	343	317	.924	26	2.45	0	637
7	Joonas Korpisalo J. Korpisalo	4	16	15	6	5	0	505	461	.913	44	2.87	1	921
8	Jonathan Bernier J. Bernier	4	16	16	5	7	0	521	471	.904	50	3.16	0	949
9	Carey Price C. Price	4	25	25	14	7	0	709	648	.914	61	2.43	2	1504
10	Craig Anderson C. Anderson	4	24	22	9	8	0	720	663	.921	57	2.61	3	1313
11	Scott Wedgewood S. Wedgewood	3	6	6	1	2	0	188	172	.915	16	2.60	1	369
12	Carter Hart C. Hart	3	13	13	4	6	0	337	300	.890	37	3.00	0	740
13	Matt Murray M. Murray	3	9	9	3	3	0	238	211	.887	27	3.08	1	526
14	Keith Kinkaid K. Kinkaid	3	11	10	3	4	0	320	291	.909	29	2.72	0	639
15	Cory Schneider C. Schneider	3	11	11	3	5	0	317	296	.934	21	1.97	0	641
16	Braden Holtby B. Holtby	3	27	26	16	6	0	768	705	.918	63	2.44	0	1547
17	Robin Lehner R. Lehner	3	13	12	6	4	0	408	372	.912	36	2.93	0	737
18	Steve Mason S. Mason	3	18	18	9	4	0	552	511	.926	41	2.40	2	1027
19	Ondrej Pavelec O. Pavelec	3	16	16	4	9	0	477	429	.899	48	3.15	1	914
20	Jaroslav Halak J. Halak	3	14	13	7	4	0	408	374	.917	34	2.58	2	791
21	Ryan Miller R. Miller	3	33	33	19	10	0	995	901	.906	94	2.98	2	1892
22	Roberto Luongo R. Luongo	3	33	30	13	12	1	967	890	.920	77	2.57	0	1799
23	Andrew Raycroft A. Raycroft	3	13	12	3	5	1	316	281	.889	35	2.79	0	754
24	Olie Kolzig O. Kolzig	3	42	35	26	10	2	1,073	976	.910	97	2.35	3	2474
25	Pyotr Kochetkov P. Kochetkov	2	9	8	5	2	0	214	191	.893	23	2.74	2	504