Between the 1989-90 and 1998-99 seasons, Jaromir Jagr recorded the most points for the Penguins, with 862 points.

	NAME	P	GP	G	A	+/-	PIM	PPG	PPA	SHG	SHA	GWG	OTG	S	S%
1	Jaromir Jagr J. Jagr	862	662	345	517	+163	501	86	167	8	3	63	8	2,304	15.0
2	Mario Lemieux M. Lemieux	779	377	313	466	+107	391	101	194	25	13	40	2	1,607	19.5
3	Ron Francis R. Francis	613	533	164	449	+70	295	54	193	5	16	21	1	1,201	13.7
4	Kevin Stevens K. Stevens	505	418	234	271	-13	941	102	95	0	0	24	3	1,447	16.2
5	Joe Mullen J. Mullen	325	379	153	172	+64	101	43	43	7	3	22	1	858	17.8
6	Larry Murphy L. Murphy	301	336	78	223	+102	213	26	104	4	4	12	1	881	8.9
7	Paul Coffey P. Coffey	260	210	63	197	-39	285	23	96	0	3	7	0	771	8.2
8	Mark Recchi M. Recchi	250	210	103	147	-10	170	34	50	3	1	17	1	483	21.3
9	John Cullen J. Cullen	223	183	76	147	-17	287	21	52	0	1	7	0	456	16.7
10	Martin Straka M. Straka	221	312	91	130	+37	123	11	30	7	5	15	0	488	18.6
11	Rick Tocchet R. Tocchet	179	150	76	103	+25	435	29	34	6	1	8	0	449	16.9
12	Petr Nedved P. Nedved	170	154	78	92	+35	134	20	26	4	2	9	0	393	19.8
13	Rob Brown R. Brown	160	245	67	93	-26	208	27	31	0	0	8	1	439	15.3
14	Tomas Sandstrom T. Sandstrom	155	172	71	84	+14	168	22	22	3	5	6	0	448	15.8
15	Kevin Hatcher K. Hatcher	140	220	45	95	+19	193	26	39	3	3	7	2	499	9.0
16	Stu Barnes S. Barnes	136	204	67	69	-17	66	32	18	1	2	11	0	483	13.9
17	Bob Errey B. Errey	130	289	67	63	+13	419	0	1	5	2	6	0	459	14.6
18	Shawn McEachern S. McEachern	112	170	53	59	+39	78	8	11	4	1	8	0	385	13.8
19	Phil Bourque P. Bourque	99	212	52	47	-6	272	3	5	6	3	6	1	283	18.4
20	Ulf Samuelsson U. Samuelsson	94	277	11	83	+76	804	2	19	0	6	2	1	339	3.2
21	Troy Loney T. Loney	90	269	33	57	-3	479	0	2	0	0	5	1	306	10.8
22	Zarley Zalapski Z. Zalapski	79	117	18	61	+1	96	10	28	1	1	3	0	220	8.2
23	Bryan Trottier B. Trottier	72	156	24	48	-18	114	3	5	2	2	0	0	215	11.2
24	Markus Naslund M. Naslund	67	151	25	42	+14	65	4	5	0	0	4	0	218	11.5
25	Robert Lang R. Lang	66	123	30	36	-4	38	8	8	1	0	5	0	201	14.9