Mike Bossy has put up the most career goals for the Islanders, with 573 scored.

	NAME	G	GP	A	P	+/-	PIM	PPG	PPA	SHG	SHA	GWG	OTG	S	S%	FOW	FO	FOW%	HIT	BKS	TKA	GVA	TOI/GP
1	Mike Bossy M. Bossy	573	752	553	1,126	+380	210	180	198	8	1	80	4	2,709	21.2
2	Bryan Trottier B. Trottier	500	1,123	853	1,353	+467	798	158	257	17	18	69	1	2,626	19.0
3	Denis Potvin D. Potvin	310	1,060	742	1,052	+456	1,356	127	332	10	22	44	0	3,050	10.2
4	Clark Gillies C. Gillies	304	872	359	663	+244	891	92	104	0	0	41	0	2,124	14.3
5	Brock Nelson B. Nelson	295	901	279	574	+9	318	61	58	5	2	47	9	2,080	14.2	4,837	10,093	47.9	614	534	478	443	16:58
6	Anders Lee A. Lee	295	869	227	522	+18	521	79	49	0	0	44	1	2,193	13.5	390	821	47.5	1,441	448	252	355	16:20
7	Pat LaFontaine P. LaFontaine	287	530	279	566	+7	309	79	104	5	0	35	4	1,639	17.5
8	Brent Sutter B. Sutter	287	694	323	610	+120	761	90	86	12	5	37	1	1,661	17.3
9	John Tavares J. Tavares	272	669	349	621	-42	307	83	130	3	3	42	11	2,110	12.9	6,287	12,259	51.3	318	235	586	643	20:01
10	Bob Bourne B. Bourne	238	814	304	542	+162	542	38	52	16	12	37	1	1,573	15.1
11	Bobby Nystrom B. Nystrom	235	900	278	513	+110	1,248	27	22	0	0	38	0	1,823	12.9
12	Derek King D. King	211	638	288	499	+3	344	81	94	1	0	30	1	1,409	15.0
13	John Tonelli J. Tonelli	206	594	338	544	+215	473	35	72	3	2	29	1	1,108	18.6
14	Josh Bailey J. Bailey	184	1,057	396	580	-48	241	34	110	6	3	24	6	1,591	11.6	1,675	3,818	43.9	535	509	622	701	16:32
15	Billy Harris B. Harris	184	623	259	443	+41	296	38	70	3	6	24		1,340	13.7
16	Ziggy Palffy Z. Palffy	168	331	163	331	-7	173	46	67	9	5	19	0	1,074	15.6
17	Patrick Flatley P. Flatley	160	712	328	488	+57	660	42	55	6	7	21	2	1,309	12.2
18	Pierre Turgeon P. Turgeon	147	255	193	340	+9	70	50	76	6	4	24	4	841	17.5
19	Mariusz Czerkawski M. Czerkawski	145	470	150	295	-39	183	47	48	1	1	14	2	1,230	11.8	7	28	25.0	251	82	145	219	16:26
20	Mathew Barzal M. Barzal	142	557	341	483	+16	270	25	112	0	0	22	6	1,341	10.6	1,473	3,521	41.8	244	288	426	655	18:55
21	Kyle Okposo K. Okposo	139	529	230	369	-60	310	35	71	0	3	22	6	1,346	10.3	446	927	48.1	447	244	397	321	18:33
22	Jason Blake J. Blake	127	426	131	258	+5	268	31	29	8	9	17	2	1,314	9.7	227	502	45.2	451	175	309	205	17:06
23	Duane Sutter D. Sutter	121	547	171	292	+36	893	14	23	0	0	8	0	948	12.8
24	Frans Nielsen F. Nielsen	119	606	230	349	+4	112	26	89	15	6	13	1	1,157	10.3	3,882	8,069	48.1	276	489	401	260	16:55
25	Alexei Yashin A. Yashin	119	346	171	290	-24	179	47	77	0	1	18	1	1,117	10.7	1,954	4,148	47.1	152	99	159	180	18:35