Since 1990-91, Frank Pietrangelo has the highest goals-against average, with a 4.12 average.

Interpreted as:

worst goals against average with a minimum of 20.5 games played per 82 team games by a player after 1990

	NAME	GAA	GP	GS	W	L	T	OTL	SA	SV	SV%	GA	SHO	MIN
1	Frank Pietrangelo F. Pietrangelo	4.12	84		24	39	4		2,256	1,968	.872	288	0	4199
2	Peter Ing P. Ing	3.96	71		20	35	8		2,070	1,822	.880	248	1	3759
3	Peter Sidorkiewicz P. Sidorkiewicz	3.76	155	0	38	90	16		4,024	3,492	.868	532	3	8486
4	Daniel Berthiaume D. Berthiaume	3.74	90		30	42	8		2,524	2,223	.881	301	1	4824
5	Mike Liut M. Liut	3.73	56		23	23	5		1,344	1,160	.863	184	1	2958
6	Troy Gamble T. Gamble	3.71	66		20	25	9		1,674	1,461	.873	213	1	3442
7	Robb Stauber R. Stauber	3.70	60		21	22	9		1,849	1,651	.893	198	1	3211
8	Tommy Soderstrom T. Soderstrom	3.63	156		45	69	19		4,265	3,769	.884	496	10	8189
9	Joel Blomqvist J. Blomqvist	3.60	8	7	3	5	0	0	261	236	.904	25	0	416
10	Kay Whitmore K. Whitmore	3.55	143	3	54	61	15		3,771	3,299	.875	472	4	7975
11	Clint Malarchuk C. Malarchuk	3.52	66		22	27	13		1,993	1,772	.889	221	1	3770
12	Tim Cheveldae T. Cheveldae	3.46	310		139	125	29		8,602	7,596	.883	1,006	10	17450
13	Bill Ranford B. Ranford	3.45	511	63	179	234	61		14,686	13,047	.888	1,639	10	28523
14	Michael Garnett M. Garnett	3.44	24	20	10	7		4	634	561	.885	73	2	1271
15	Craig Billington C. Billington	3.44	289	72	101	126	28		7,272	6,415	.882	857	9	14944
16	Karel Vejmelka K. Vejmelka	3.39	155	144	48	82	0	13	4,839	4,352	.899	487	5	8610
17	Kaapo Kahkonen K. Kahkonen	3.34	140	132	49	68	0	15	4,228	3,797	.898	431	4	7744
18	Kelly Hrudey K. Hrudey	3.33	368	22	133	150	54		11,184	10,038	.898	1,146	8	20631
19	Sam Montembeault S. Montembeault	3.31	166	149	58	71	0	23	5,002	4,496	.899	506	4	9164
20	Milan Hnilicka M. Hnilicka	3.31	121	107	29	67	13		3,598	3,239	.900	359	5	6509
21	Aleksei Kolosov A. Kolosov	3.29	9	7	3	5	0	1	235	207	.881	28	0	510
22	Lukas Dostal L. Dostal	3.28	83	74	25	42	0	9	2,638	2,389	.906	249	2	4554
23	Jeff Deslauriers J. Deslauriers	3.24	62	59	23	32		4	1,944	1,751	.901	193	3	3578
24	Dan Blackburn D. Blackburn	3.22	63	55	20	32	4		1,777	1,589	.894	188	1	3500
25	Ken Wregget K. Wregget	3.21	321	61	147	111	33		8,914	7,970	.894	944	7	17651