Brian Sutter scored the most goals when spending 5+ minutes in the box, with 73 scored.

Interpreted as:

most career goals by a player in games of 5+ pim

	NAME	G	PIM	GP	A	P	+/-	PPG	PPA	SHG	SHA	GWG	OTG	S	S%	FOW	FO	FOW%	HIT	BKS	TKA	GVA	TOI/GP
1	Brian Sutter B. Sutter	73	1,296	164	63	136	-8	24	19	1	1	8	0	367	19.9
2	Brendan Shanahan B. Shanahan	68	1,435	146	67	135	+14	27	20	1	4	11	0	406	16.7	7	20	35.0	37	17	14	32	17:41
3	Dave Williams D. Williams	67	3,201	296	77	144	+10	16	10	1	2	6	0	467	14.3
4	Rick Tocchet R. Tocchet	65	1,996	216	90	155	-8	22	28	3	1	8	0	443	14.7	0	0		14	1	8	7	12:29
5	Al Secord A. Secord	53	1,499	157	40	93	+4	12	9	0	0	5	0	287	18.5
6	Dale Hunter D. Hunter	49	2,203	250	105	154	+1	14	21	3	5	4	1	325	15.1
7	Keith Tkachuk K. Tkachuk	45	1,075	115	46	91	-11	20	14	1	1	3	1	317	14.2	153	304	50.3	42	7	11	30	17:51
8	Pat Verbeek P. Verbeek	45	1,431	145	57	102	+1	19	20	0	1	5	0	306	14.7	0	0		16	1	3	1	12:15
9	Wilf Paiement W. Paiement	45	961	116	61	106	+3	11	17	1	1	5	0	316	14.2
10	Wendel Clark W. Clark	44	1,148	140	33	77	-35	16	11	0	0	6	0	342	12.9	0	0		2	0	0	1	7:52
11	Gary Roberts G. Roberts	43	1,646	157	44	87	+1	9	9	0	0	1	0	288	14.9	2	2	100.0	67	8	13	12	15:40
12	Dave Taylor D. Taylor	43	815	101	57	100	+21	14	26	1	0	5	0	205	21.0
13	Scott Mellanby S. Mellanby	42	1,361	163	51	93	-21	18	17	0	1	5	0	315	13.3	2	8	25.0	37	9	11	14	14:39
14	Bob Probert B. Probert	41	2,634	259	55	96	+18	7	11	0	0	5	1	301	13.6	5	15	33.3	40	7	5	7	7:01
15	Mark Messier M. Messier	41	794	90	62	103	+27	11	19	2	3	6	0	197	20.8	43	82	52.4	4	0	1	5	13:11
16	Ted Lindsay T. Lindsay	40	1,020	99	54	94	+1	13	19	2	0	9	0	24	4.2
17	Eric Lindros E. Lindros	37	542	62	38	75	+19	10	10	2	0	5	0	179	20.7	143	273	52.4	38	12	11	10	17:30
18	Shayne Corson S. Corson	37	1,453	173	58	95	+2	11	13	1	1	4	0	310	11.9	116	248	46.8	64	7	7	18	14:36
19	Cam Neely C. Neely	37	721	91	36	73	+16	11	16	0	0	2	1	217	17.1
20	Mike Foligno M. Foligno	37	1,255	133	49	86	-16	15	17	0	0	6	0	265	14.0
21	Maurice Richard M. Richard	37	647	69	29	66	+1	9	7	0	1	5	0	3	33.3
22	Willi Plett W. Plett	36	1,770	170	48	84	-5	5	13	0	0	5	0	223	16.1
23	Jeremy Roenick J. Roenick	35	657	72	26	61	-4	13	10	3	0	5	1	192	18.2	161	348	46.3	43	13	5	20	16:56
24	Mel Bridgman M. Bridgman	35	1,139	113	48	83	+36	10	7	3	0	5	0	192	18.2
25	Owen Nolan O. Nolan	34	963	110	46	80	+15	9	16	2	1	7	0	272	12.5	79	154	51.3	59	8	20	24	16:51