Between the 2003-04 and 2012-13 seasons, Chris Neil had the most penalty minutes, with 1,627 minutes in the box.

Interpreted as:

most penalty minutes by a player 2003-04 to 2012-13

	NAME	PIM	GP	G	A	P	+/-	PPG	PPA	SHG	SHA	GWG	OTG	S	S%	FOW	FO	FOW%	HIT	BKS	TKA	GVA	TOI/GP
1	Chris Neil C. Neil	1,627	639	78	107	185	-13	14	15	0	0	12	0	897	8.7	22	60	36.7	2,058	139	219	150	12:05
2	Sean Avery S. Avery	1,312	493	82	146	228	+8	10	28	4	2	12	0	1,078	7.6	350	727	48.1	777	127	149	216	13:46
3	Steve Ott S. Ott	1,232	588	91	146	237	-15	22	26	4	9	15	2	848	10.7	2,281	4,152	54.9	1,756	201	183	272	15:12
4	Scott Hartnell S. Hartnell	1,089	643	202	192	394	+60	73	45	4	4	39	4	1,555	13.0	163	390	41.8	936	264	251	336	16:31
5	Daniel Carcillo D. Carcillo	1,079	333	40	47	87	-19	9	7	0	0	5	0	479	8.4	20	35	57.1	694	79	81	83	11:01
6	Colton Orr C. Orr	1,076	422	12	12	24	-30	0	0	0	0	4	0	161	7.5	6	23	26.1	620	105	39	34	6:09
7	Jody Shelley J. Shelley	1,073	506	14	29	43	-31	1	1	0	0	2	0	317	4.4	8	33	24.2	727	83	40	62	6:07
8	George Parros G. Parros	1,007	452	18	17	35	-5	0	0	0	0	1	0	210	8.6	5	25	20.0	541	108	38	64	6:00
9	Zenon Konopka Z. Konopka	994	287	11	16	27	-40	3	3	0	0	2	0	179	6.1	1,420	2,408	59.0	340	112	40	49	8:33
10	Jared Boll J. Boll	963	388	24	28	52	-27	1	1	0	0	5	0	312	7.7	9	33	27.3	731	73	63	35	8:00
11	Zdeno Chara Z. Chara	922	675	119	268	387	+165	69	99	3	13	17	2	1,873	6.4	12	33	36.4	1,629	918	281	603	25:58
12	Eric Boulton E. Boulton	900	487	23	36	59	-33	1	0	0	0	1	0	345	6.7	7	23	30.4	524	93	75	66	6:51
13	Jarkko Ruutu J. Ruutu	900	538	51	71	122	-13	3	2	2	5	7	0	534	9.6	28	96	29.2	871	203	192	140	11:20
14	Ben Eager B. Eager	873	400	43	41	84	-13	0	0	0	0	6	0	400	10.8	2	11	18.2	515	88	87	96	8:34
15	Darcy Hordichuk D. Hordichuk	864	469	19	20	39	-15	0	1	0	0	3	0	225	8.4	3	8	37.5	806	33	55	55	5:31
16	Cody McLeod C. McLeod	856	396	45	33	78	-33	2	1	0	1	4	0	509	8.8	18	49	36.7	865	117	82	35	10:41
17	Shane O'Brien S. O'Brien	853	483	13	75	88	+18	2	5	0	3	3	0	409	3.2	0	0		748	469	159	231	17:17
18	Donald Brashear D. Brashear	847	396	20	28	48	-24	0	1	0	0	1	0	312	6.4	11	34	32.4	634	70	95	149	8:27
19	Jamal Mayers J. Mayers	844	627	60	87	147	-88	0	2	6	4	10	0	812	7.4	2,007	3,701	54.2	706	227	195	169	11:58
20	Alexandre Burrows A. Burrows	825	569	152	142	294	+131	10	9	16	5	24	1	1,119	13.6	141	328	43.0	591	269	325	157	15:54
21	Mike Rupp M. Rupp	811	571	49	41	90	-29	2	4	0	1	6	0	548	8.9	682	1,389	49.1	995	111	78	99	8:37
22	Jordin Tootoo J. Tootoo	803	528	49	84	133	-26	3	4	0	0	6	0	833	5.9	45	90	50.0	858	87	179	194	10:29
23	Dion Phaneuf D. Phaneuf	801	600	106	234	340	+1	61	123	1	3	25	5	1,717	6.2	0	0		1,478	790	254	486	25:01
24	Shawn Thornton S. Thornton	801	482	32	46	78	-10	0	1	1	0	5	0	730	4.4	74	165	44.8	663	83	116	42	9:03
25	Arron Asham A. Asham	795	584	68	86	154	-25	3	5	1	0	7	0	648	10.5	63	157	40.1	1,044	143	167	129	10:06