Between the 2019-20 and 2028-29 seasons, the Tampa Bay Lightning had the most penalty minutes + opponent penalty minutes by a team in a home game, with 180 against the Panthers on February 17, 2024.

NHL home team most penalty minute + penalty minute allowed in a regular-season game 2020s

	TEAM	PIM+OPP PIM	PIM	OPP PIM	DATE	TM		OPP	RESULT	G	GA	PPG	PPO	OPP PPG	OPP PPO	S	SA
1	Lightning	180	90	90	2/17/2024	TBL	vs	FLA	L 2-9	2	9	1	4	3	4	30	30
2	Senators	167	84	83	11/27/2023	OTT	vs	FLA	L 0-5	0	5	0	6	3	7	20	37
3	Rangers	166	78	88	4/3/2024	NYR	vs	NJD	W 4-3	4	3	1	3	0	3	41	20
4	Panthers	166	78	88	4/6/2023	FLA	vs	OTT	W 7-2	7	2	3	6	0	6	30	58
5	Kings	154	75	79	3/20/2024	LAK	vs	MIN	W 6-0	6	0	2	4	0	2	27	31
6	Panthers	154	76	78	5/8/2021	FLA	vs	TBL	W 5-1	5	1	1	6	0	5	35	29
7	Red Wings	150	67	83	3/12/2025	DET	vs	BUF	W 7-3	7	3	3	6	1	3	29	26
8	Lightning	146	71	75	3/9/2023	TBL	vs	VGK	L 3-4	3	4	1	5	1	2	37	21
9	Hurricanes	142	68	74	4/2/2025	CAR	vs	WSH	W 5-1	5	1	3	8	1	4	31	21
10	Rangers	141	85	56	5/5/2021	NYR	vs	WSH	L 2-4	2	4	0	2	2	7	21	35
11	Sabres	132	70	62	3/30/2024	BUF	vs	TOR	L 0-3	0	3	0	6	0	4	34	22
12	Lightning	114	49	65	4/21/2022	TBL	vs	TOR	W 8-1	8	1	3	5	1	5	36	37
13	Ducks	110	57	53	11/9/2022	ANA	vs	MIN	L 1-4	1	4	0	4	2	6	32	39
14	Bruins	104	47	57	10/29/2019	BOS	vs	SJS	W 5-1	5	1	2	8	1	3	41	17
15	Flames	102	57	45	2/1/2020	CGY	vs	EDM	L 3-8	3	8	0	2	1	3	26	49
16	Bruins	94	46	48	3/7/2020	BOS	vs	TBL	L 3-5	3	5	1	4	1	3	38	25
17	Lightning	92	37	55	11/14/2019	TBL	vs	NYR	W 9-3	9	3	5	8	0	4	45	23
18	Canadiens	90	53	37	1/19/2023	MTL	vs	FLA	L 2-6	2	6	0	5	4	8	25	40
19	Panthers	90	66	24	4/24/2022	FLA	vs	TBL	L 4-8	4	8	1	6	3	7	39	33
20	Blackhawks	88	45	43	3/12/2024	CHI	vs	ANA	W 7-2	7	2	4	6	0	2	31	29
21	Rangers	88	50	38	1/13/2020	NYR	vs	NYI	W 6-2	6	2	1	2	1	3	36	34
22	Coyotes	86	48	38	1/8/2022	ARI	vs	NSH	L 2-4	2	4	0	6	1	6	40	29
23	Flyers	86	40	46	10/18/2021	PHI	vs	SEA	W 6-1	6	1	0	2	0	4	27	24
24	Canadiens	84	40	44	10/17/2023	MTL	vs	MIN	L 2-5	2	5	0	5	3	8	28	35
25	Senators	84	49	35	2/20/2020	OTT	vs	WPG	L 1-5	1	5	0	4	3	6	30	34