Between the 1917-18 and 1918-19 seasons, Cy Denneny scored the most goals, with 54 scored.

NHL most career goals by a player 1917-18 to 1918-19

	NAME	G	GP	A	P	PIM	GWG	OTG
1	Cy Denneny C. Denneny	54	39	16	70	135	4	0
2	Joe Malone J. Malone	51	28	6	57	33	4	1
3	Newsy Lalonde N. Lalonde	46	31	16	62	93	2	0
4	Reg Noble R. Noble	39	37	14	53	78	6	0
5	Didier Pitre D. Pitre	31	37	12	43	44	8	0
6	Frank Nighbor F. Nighbor	30	28	17	47	36	4	0
7	Harry Cameron H. Cameron	28	35	15	43	63	3	2
8	Corb Denneny C. Denneny	28	37	13	41	29	2	0
9	Jack Darragh J. Darragh	25	32	9	34	53	4	0
10	Alf Skinner A. Skinner	25	37	10	35	60	1	0
11	Odie Cleghorn O. Cleghorn	21	18	6	27	30	1	0
12	Ken Randall K. Randall	21	36	8	29	163	5	0
13	Jack McDonald J. McDonald	20	31	6	26	21	3	1
14	Harry Meeking H. Meeking	18	35	13	31	60	1	0
15	Eddie Gerard E. Gerard	17	38	17	34	43	0	0
16	Joe Hall J. Hall	15	37	9	24	230	1	0
17	Harry Hyland H. Hyland	14	17	2	16	65	2	0
18	George Boucher G. Boucher	12	38	10	22	75	1	0
19	Bert Corbeau B. Corbeau	10	37	10	20	98	1	0
20	Rusty Crawford R. Crawford	10	38	8	18	115	0	0
21	Dave Ritchie D. Ritchie	9	21	3	12	30	2	0
22	Sprague Cleghorn S. Cleghorn	7	18	8	15	27	2	0
23	Louis Berlinquette L. Berlinquette	7	38	5	12	24	2	0
24	Harry Mummery H. Mummery	5	31	3	8	76	1	0
25	Punch Broadbent P. Broadbent	4	8	3	7	12	1	1