Between the 1917-18 and 1924-25 seasons, Cy Denneny had the most goals, with 202 scored.

NHL most career goals by a player 1917-18 to 1924-25

	NAME	G	GP	A	P	PIM	GWG	OTG
1	Cy Denneny C. Denneny	202	184	69	271	250	30	5
2	Babe Dye B. Dye	159	141	38	197	163	27	2
3	Joe Malone J. Malone	143	126	33	176	57	11	3
4	Reg Noble R. Noble	132	187	69	201	387	12	1
5	Newsy Lalonde N. Lalonde	125	98	42	167	183	14	1
6	Frank Nighbor F. Nighbor	110	163	71	181	118	20	2
7	Punch Broadbent P. Broadbent	95	138	35	130	251	18	5
8	Odie Cleghorn O. Cleghorn	92	160	34	126	142	9	0
9	Corb Denneny C. Denneny	91	129	41	132	114	7	1
10	George Boucher G. Boucher	88	179	61	149	387	14	0
11	Harry Cameron H. Cameron	88	129	54	142	180	15	3
12	Billy Boucher B. Boucher	74	101	30	104	213	17	1
13	Sprague Cleghorn S. Cleghorn	70	153	52	122	398	9	1
14	Jack Darragh J. Darragh	68	121	49	117	107	12	0
15	Ken Randall K. Randall	65	182	49	114	487	15	0
16	Didier Pitre D. Pitre	64	127	35	99	87	12	0
17	Goldie Prodgers G. Prodgers	63	111	33	96	39	5	1
18	Mickey Roach M. Roach	63	142	36	99	38	8	1
19	Aurel Joliat A. Joliat	58	73	28	86	139	13	1
20	Bert Corbeau B. Corbeau	57	181	41	98	452	6	0
21	Jack Adams J. Adams	55	97	35	90	262	9	0
22	Amos Arbour A. Arbour	52	114	17	69	78	5	1
23	Cully Wilson C. Wilson	51	88	24	75	203	1	0
24	Eddie Gerard E. Gerard	50	128	51	101	126	3	0
25	Louis Berlinquette L. Berlinquette	45	163	32	77	124	7	0