Between the 1979-80 and 1988-89 seasons, Dave Williams had the most penalty minutes, with 2,498 minutes in the box.

	NAME	PIM	GP	G	A	P	+/-	PPG	PPA	SHG	SHA	GWG	OTG	S	S%
1	Dave Williams D. Williams	2,498	610	154	158	312	-53	31	30	2	2	13	1	1,029	15.0
2	Chris Nilan C. Nilan	2,447	566	97	96	193	+9	7	5	0	0	9	0	700	13.9
3	Willi Plett W. Plett	2,063	614	144	151	295	-65	28	26	0	0	14	0	892	16.1
4	Dale Hunter D. Hunter	2,004	682	182	392	574	+116	40	63	9	12	17	1	1,110	16.4
5	Laurie Boschman L. Boschman	1,861	720	191	295	486	-100	38	56	6	6	24	2	1,224	15.6
6	Al Secord A. Secord	1,839	652	243	209	452	-5	65	51	0	0	28	1	1,479	16.4
7	Tim Hunter T. Hunter	1,816	414	41	51	92	+18	3	3	0	0	5	0	354	11.6
8	Larry Playfair L. Playfair	1,752	658	26	90	116	-21	0	2	0	1	2	0	450	5.8
9	Jim Korn J. Korn	1,676	551	64	117	181	-131	11	19	4	3	6	0	583	11.0
10	Mike Foligno M. Foligno	1,654	758	305	317	622	+78	74	76	2	4	46	1	1,763	17.3
11	Torrie Robertson T. Robertson	1,639	400	48	94	142	-47	7	14	0	0	9	0	368	13.0
12	Jay Wells J. Wells	1,630	671	36	162	198	-27	11	49	0	6	6	0	821	4.4
13	Rob Ramage R. Ramage	1,620	755	112	339	451	-139	61	162	1	7	17	2	2,301	4.9
14	Paul Baxter P. Baxter	1,564	472	48	121	169	-63	15	31	1	0	5	0	710	6.8
15	Glen Cochrane G. Cochrane	1,556	410	17	72	89	+62	0	5	1	2	5	0	313	5.4
16	Ken Linseman K. Linseman	1,510	711	233	477	710	+187	56	140	11	9	28	3	1,450	16.1
17	Scott Stevens S. Stevens	1,474	545	87	302	389	+89	39	123	1	2	14	1	1,156	7.5
18	Jim Peplinski J. Peplinski	1,452	699	160	262	422	+55	5	12	8	4	22	2	1,252	12.8
19	Brian Sutter B. Sutter	1,416	589	249	271	520	-18	91	75	3	4	25	2	1,361	18.3
20	Kevin McClelland K. McClelland	1,415	490	63	105	168	-23	0	3	4	1	8	0	574	11.0
21	Harold Snepsts H. Snepsts	1,371	598	17	112	129	-25	0	2	1	6	2	0	513	3.3
22	Terry Ruskowski T. Ruskowski	1,354	629	113	313	426	-63	34	71	4	8	19	0	643	17.6
23	Pat Price P. Price	1,352	544	35	173	208	+1	4	36	0	3	2	0	581	6.0
24	Mario Marois M. Marois	1,321	695	64	297	361	+31	16	91	0	8	3	1	1,417	4.5
25	Ed Hospodar E. Hospodar	1,314	450	17	51	68	-45	0	3	1	1	1	0	324	5.2