The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the Montreal Maroons, 4 to 3, on November 22, 1927.
1st period
MMR
NYR
Red Dutton unassisted
1
0
Frank Boucher assisted by Bill Cook
1
1
Russell Oatman assisted by Merlyn Phillips
2
1
2nd period
MMR
NYR
Alex Gray unassisted
2
2
Babe Siebert unassisted
3
2
3rd period
MMR
NYR
Nels Stewart assisted by Red Dutton
4
2
Alex Gray assisted by Paul Thompson
4
3