The Pittsburgh Penguins couldn't pull it off against the Toronto Maple Leafs, 2 to 1, on November 24, 1971.
1st period
TOR
PIT
Norm Ullman (PP) assisted by Dave Keon and Jim McKenny
1
0
2nd period
TOR
PIT
Paul Henderson (PP) assisted by Jim McKenny and Dave Keon
2
0
3rd period
TOR
PIT
Greg Polis (PP) assisted by Ken Schinkel and Darryl Edestrand
2
1