The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the Montreal Canadiens, 3 to 2, on November 27, 1934.
1st period
MTL
NYR
Murray Murdoch (EV) assisted by Bun Cook
0
1
Jack McGill (EV) assisted by Nels Crutchfield
1
1
Joe Lamb (EV) assisted by Jack Riley and Armand Mondou
2
1
2nd period
MTL
NYR
Armand Mondou (EV) unassisted
3
1
Frank Boucher (EV) assisted by Ching Johnson
3
2