Since 1999-00, Romelu Lukaku has tallied the most goals by an Everton player in the Premier League, with 68 goals.

	NAME	G	M	MIN	START	G/M	A	G+A	PK	FK	SH	SOT	WOOD	TCH	TCH-BOX	OFF
1	Romelu Lukaku R. Lukaku	68	141	11,881	133	0.48	21	89	4
2	Dominic Calvert-Lewin D. Calvert-Lewin	57	239	15,724	179	0.24	15	72	5	0	457	193	12	6,211	819	128
3	Tim Cahill T. Cahill	56	226	18,012	210	0.25	22	78	0
4	Leon Osman L. Osman	44	352	26,050	295	0.13	26	70	0
5	Richarlison	43	135	11,142	129	0.32	12	55	4	0	326	115	9	5,544	625	79
6	Kevin Campbell K. Campbell	36	137	10,473	117	0.26	13	49	0
7	Kevin Mirallas K. Mirallas	29	151	8,807	104	0.19	17	46	0
8	Leighton Baines L. Baines	29	348	29,202	327	0.08	53	82	19
9	Louis Saha L. Saha	27	97	6,138	65	0.28	2	29	3
10	Mikel Arteta M. Arteta	27	174	14,593	166	0.16	36	63	10
11	Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson G. Þór Sigurðsson	25	136	10,213	113	0.18	17	42	6	0	220	77	6	5,719	273	6
12	Marouane Fellaini M. Fellaini	25	141	11,727	132	0.18	15	40	0
13	Yakubu Aiyegbeni Y. Aiyegbeni	25	82	5,051	56	0.30	8	33	1
14	Wayne Rooney W. Rooney	25	98	6,308	67	0.26	10	35	3
15	Tomasz Radziński T. Radziński	25	91	6,890	78	0.27	10	35	0
16	Duncan Ferguson D. Ferguson	23	123	5,906	52	0.19	8	31	3
17	Séamus Coleman S. Coleman	22	372	28,906	327	0.06	24	46	0
18	David Unsworth D. Unsworth	22	154	11,904	131	0.14	8	30	13
19	Ross Barkley R. Barkley	21	150	10,668	119	0.14	18	39	2
20	Steven Pienaar S. Pienaar	20	189	15,099	171	0.11	31	51	0
21	Abdoulaye Doucouré A. Doucouré	19	149	11,704	138	0.13	12	31	0	0	150	57	2	6,337	307	40
22	Steven Naismith S. Naismith	19	103	5,201	52	0.18	4	23	0
23	Andy Johnson A. Johnson	17	61	4,563	52	0.28	6	23	1
24	Victor Anichebe V. Anichebe	17	131	5,703	58	0.13	9	26	0
25	Michael Keane M. Keane	16	210	17,575	193	0.08	8	24	0	0	137	41	4	11,327	253	5